乐鱼 体育

鈥淭he war, which we are trying to stop, which was launched against us using the Ukrainian people....鈥� At a recent G20 event in India the audience laughed at  by Sergei Lavrov, Russia鈥檚 foreign minister. For those who do not live in an upside-down world, this phrase may indeed sound funny in its blatant disregard for the truth.  

But to those who know Russia well this is not funny. The notion of Russia as a victim of a war waged against it is the official narrative disseminated in all seriousness by its chief propagandist, Vladimir Putin. He regularly, in different versions,  these words: 鈥淭hey were the ones who started this war, while we are using force to stop it.鈥� The original wording of this phrase belongs to none other than Vladimir Zelensky, who, in his 2019 inaugural address, : 鈥淲e are not the ones who have started this war. But we are the ones who have to finish it.鈥�

If you think about it, the idea of Russia as a victim must sound outlandish, especially when uttered by someone who believes that might makes right and that Russia is a mighty nuclear power that cannot be defeated militarily. And yet lots of Russians keep listening and agreeing that Russia is both the unfortunate victim of the insidious and powerful West and a great power ready to bury the weak and degrading West. There are two unavoidable parts to almost every Putin speech鈥攖he first, in which he whines about how Russia has been wronged, and the second, in which he threatens the world with Russia鈥檚 power.

Logical contradictions, deception, manipulation of facts, refusal to call things by their proper names, and projecting onto others what they accuse you of are all tools Putin uses to shape reality. Even though the pictures he creates for his listeners could be compared to the impossible spaces in M. C. Escher鈥檚 engravings, we are all hostages to his world because the wars he wages are quite real. Though he explains to his audiences that he does not wage them. 

Yes, in his depiction, Putin is both waging and not waging a war. Putin does not call what he started in Ukraine a war but a 鈥渟pecial military operation.鈥� He only uses the word 鈥渨ar鈥� to describe what鈥攊n his mind鈥攐thers are doing. The same applies to the words 鈥渁ggression鈥� or 鈥渂litzkrieg鈥� ("the West鈥檚 economic blitzkrieg failed鈥�). Putin seeks to end this war and for this purpose is conducting a 鈥渟pecial military operation鈥� and will continue to do so until it is over. That is, in translation, he will wage war until he finishes waging war. 

Russia both bears and does not bear war-related losses. The authorities do not deny that people die while performing 鈥渟pecial operation tasks,鈥� but they do not publicize losses or even laud the heroes. A lot of the mobilized are from faraway provinces. The strategy is to spread the losses as thinly as possible across the country. Low-profile memorial services are held from time to time but only at the regional level. In his speeches, Putin speaks only about the benefits of the 鈥渟pecial operation.鈥� Troops are entitled to regular vacations and medical treatment, which will be paid for out of a special sovereign fund. According to Putin, people who have 鈥渨orked鈥� in the "special operation鈥� must form the government鈥檚 personnel reserve.

Russia is both mobilizing and not mobilizing. Last year鈥檚 mobilization decree has not been revoked. According to Putin, the mobilization is over, but his words are not legally binding. Realizing that mobilization鈥攑articularly when it is called that鈥攊s unpopular, the authorities are doing everything to conduct it covertly. A creeping campaign, spread through the country continues. Regular conscripts who are not supposed to serve on the battlefields are pushed or forced to sign contracts with the military, thus replenishing the Russian force deployed in Ukraine.  

Private military companies both exist and do not exist in Russia. The Wagner military company was until recently allowed to recruit in prisons. Now it is recruiting in sports clubs. Nothing like this would be possible in Russia without a directive from the highest authority, but no such directive has been published. The prisoners who have served on the front and survived were  by presidential decrees, but the decrees were not published. Neither the famous Wagner military company nor any of the other, lesser-known companies can exist, according to Russian law, which expressly bans mercenary activity. 

Martial law is both in effect and not in effect in Russia. In a recent , Putin, referring to the law on martial law, ordered that those companies that fail to deliver on defense contracts be placed under external administration. Last October, Putin  on four regions of Ukraine illegally annexed by Russia. But the new decree in no way implies that it concerns only these four 鈥渞egions鈥� of the Russian Federation. At the same time, Putin did not announce the introduction of martial law in the entire country if only because in this case, it would have been necessary to call a war a war. 

Examples of this kind are endless. This is a special sort of language, a language of eluding responsibility. In Russia鈥檚 official discourse, what Russia is doing in Ukraine is both a tragedy caused by the actions of others and a necessary action taken by Russia. 鈥淭he current situation is our common tragedy,鈥� Putin  of Russia鈥檚 war against Ukraine. That tragedy, according to him, is caused by the policies of 鈥渢hird countries.鈥� In other speeches, Putin  his 鈥渟pecial operation鈥� as a momentous, pivotal event. He speaks of the past year, 2022, as the time of 鈥渘ecessary decisions, the most important steps toward gaining full sovereignty for Russia and a powerful consolidation of our society.鈥� That is, he is both responsible for what is happening (if he presents it as a good thing) and not responsible for it (if he presents it as a bad thing). 

A desire to avoid responsibility for bad things and attribute good things to ourselves is natural. It is not a skill that needs to be taught. In childhood and adolescence, we all go through this developmental stage in one way or another (鈥渋t wasn't me鈥�). It is not walking away from responsibility that needs mastering but taking it on.

We are witnessing a striking phenomenon. Millions of people listen, spellbound, to someone who, in every single public speech, twists and turns like a teenager caught doing something shameful. All of the features of speech behavior described above are characteristic of immature people who have done bad things and then try to pretend that what is happening has nothing to do with them. This would be funny if it were not sad, just like Lavrov鈥檚 words about 鈥渢he war that was launched against us.鈥�

袪褍褋褋泻邪褟 胁械褉褋懈褟 写邪薪薪芯泄 褋褌邪褌褜懈 斜褘谢邪 芯锌褍斜谢懈泻芯胁邪薪邪 胁 锌褉芯械泻褌械 芦袠薪褘屑懈 褋谢芯胁邪屑懈禄.

The opinions expressed in this article are those solely of the author and do not reflect the views of the Kennan Institute.