Perfect Storm? Population Pressures, Natural Resource Constraints, and Climate Change in Bangladesh
A conference organized by the 乐鱼 体育's Asia Program, Environmental Change and Security Program, and Comparative Urban Studies Project.
Few nations are more at risk from climate change鈥檚 destructive effects than Bangladesh, a low-lying, lower-riparian, populous, impoverished, and natural disaster-prone nation. The United Nations鈥 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change estimates that by 2050, sea levels in Bangladesh will have risen by two to three feet, obliterating a fifth of the country鈥檚 landmass and displacing at least 20 million people. On September 19, the Asia Program, with assistance from the Environmental Change and Security Program and Comparative Urban Studies Project, hosted a conference that examined Bangladesh鈥檚 imperiled environmental security.
The first panel focused on manifestations, drivers, and risks. Ali Riaz addressed the threat of climate refugees. Environmental stress, he said, may produce two possible responses: fight (civil conflict or external aggression) or flight (migration). In Bangladesh, the latter is the more likely outcome. Coastal communities, overwhelmed by rising sea levels and flooding, could migrate to Bangladesh鈥檚 urban areas or into neighboring India. Both scenarios pose challenges for the state, which already struggles to provide services to its urban masses and has shaky relations with New Delhi.
Mohamed Khalequzzaman examined Bangladesh鈥檚 geological vulnerability in the context of climate change. In a deltaic nation like Bangladesh, he explained, sedimentation levels must keep up with rates of sea level rise to prevent the nation from drowning. However, sediment levels now fall below 5 millimeters (mm) per year 鈥 short of the 6.5 mm Khalequzzaman calculates are necessary to keep pace with projected sea level rises. He lamented the nation鈥檚 tendency to construct large dams and embankments in the Bengal Delta, which 鈥渋solate coastal ecosystems from natural sedimentation鈥 鈥 and result in lower land elevations relative to rising sea levels.
Adnan Morshed declared that Bangladesh鈥檚 geographic center 鈥 not its southern, flood-prone coastal regions 鈥 constitutes the nation鈥檚 chief climate change threat. Here, Dhaka鈥檚 urbanization is 鈥渄estroying鈥 Bangladesh鈥檚 environment. Impelled by immense population growth (2,200 people enter Dhaka each day) and the need for land, people are occupying 鈥渧ital wetlands鈥 and rivers on the city鈥檚 eastern and western peripheries. 鈥淢anhattan-style鈥 urban grid patterns now dominate wetlands, and several rivers have become converted into land. Exacerbating this urbanization-driven environmental stress are highly polluting wetlands-based brickfields (which cater to Dhaka鈥檚 construction needs) and city vehicular gas emissions.
The second panel considered possible responses to Bangladesh鈥檚 environmental security challenges. Roger-Mark De Souza trumpeted the imperative of more gender-inclusive policies. Environmental insecurity affects women and girls disproportionately, he said. When Bangladesh is stricken by floods, females must work harder to secure drinking water and to tend to the ill; they must often take off from school; and they face a heightened risk of sexual exploitation 鈥 due, in great part, to the lack of separate facilities for women in cyclone shelters. He reported that such conditions have often led to early forced marriages after cyclones.
Shamarukh Mohiuddin discussed U.S. responses. On the whole, American funding for global climate change adaptation programs has lagged, while initiatives often focus more on short-term mitigation (such as emissions reductions) than on adaptation. She recommended that Washington鈥檚 Bangladesh-based adaptation efforts be better coordinated with those of other donors. She also suggested that to convey a greater sense of urgency, Bangladesh鈥檚 climate change threats should be more explicitly linked to national security 鈥 and particularly to how America鈥檚 strategic ally, India, would be affected by climate refugees fleeing Bangladesh.
Philip J. DeCosse highlighted Bangladeshi government success stories in the famed Sundarbans (one of the world鈥檚 largest mangrove forests). Officials have banned commercial harvesting in some areas, and shut down a highly polluting paper mill. He also praised civil society and the media for bringing attention to the Sundarban鈥檚 environmental vulnerability. As a result of efforts such as these, the Sundarbans are 鈥渃oming back,鈥 with mangrove species growing anew. Thanks to a range of actors 鈥 from the Forestry Department to civil society 鈥 these forests are now being 鈥済overned more than managed.鈥
DeCosse鈥檚 fellow panelists identified additional hopeful signs. Morshed shared a photograph of a green, pristine park in Dhaka. De Souza underscored how family planning programs have worked in Bangladesh in the past, with fertility rates brought down considerably in recent years. And several speakers spotlighted efforts by civil society and the media to bring greater attention to Bangladesh鈥檚 environmental security imperatives.
Nonetheless, major challenges remain, and panelists offered a panoply of recommendations. Khalequzzaman called for a major geological study of soil loss and siltation. De Souza implored Bangladesh to ensure that women鈥檚 roles and family planning considerations are featured in climate change negotiations and adaptation policies. Morshed advocated for imposing urban growth boundaries and enhancing public transport in cities. And several speakers spoke of the need to pursue more effective natural-resource-sharing arrangements with India. Ultimately, in the words of De Souza, it may not be possible to eliminate Bangladesh鈥檚 鈥減erfect storm鈥 鈥 yet much can be done to calm it.
Photo Credit: "," courtesy of flickr user .
Speakers


Professor, Department of Politics and Government, Illinois State University; President of the American Institute of Bangladesh Studies (AIBS)

Vice President, Sustainable Markets, Pact
Hosted By
Indo-Pacific Program
The Indo-Pacific Program promotes policy debate and intellectual discussions on US interests in the Asia-Pacific as well as political, economic, security, and social issues relating to the world鈥檚 most populous and economically dynamic region. Read more
Environmental Change and Security Program
The Environmental Change and Security Program (ECSP) explores the connections between environmental change, health, and population dynamics and their links to conflict, human insecurity, and foreign policy. Read more
Urban Sustainability Laboratory
Since 1991, the Urban Sustainability Laboratory has advanced solutions to urban challenges鈥攕uch as poverty, exclusion, insecurity, and environmental degradation鈥攂y promoting evidence-based research to support sustainable, equitable and peaceful cities. Read more